HuffPostHuffPost

Your health coach wants you to eat a quart of ice cream before you go to sleep.

This was not an attempt at reverse psychology, even as the words came out. A health coach's job is not to act as a therapist, but to offer concrete guidance when asked.

I was being pushed for solutions by my client. She needed to take a leap of faith in order to escape from the relentless carnival ride of diet culture.

The whole bar. Next time we meet, we can get a clear, guilt-free assessment of how it feels.

She was eating ice cream on her own every night. I helped her get it out of the forbidden area.

It was a challenge to wake up with the best intentions and set a bunch of rules for how to get through the day and night. Decide in advance how much to eat and what calisthenics to perform. Grow frustrated as the day wears on, abandon the goals in exchange for promises of tomorrow, heavily indulge in anticipation of upcoming deprivation, and sleep fitfully before doing it all again the next day for decades.

She struggled with her weight and impulse control, like many of my other clients. I could relate to that.

We've been told for a long time that we're bad if we eat after dark. If we don't work out, and if we don't like to cook, we're lazy. Something is wrong with you! You have to control yourself. Send in the self-care apps, trackers, diet and fitness plans that will transform you into a better person.

The most important thing I have learned over the course of my nearly 20-year career is that control. Any kind of self-care that feels more like a chore than a step toward freedom is bound to send you back to your old habits.

Control would be the word I would use to shatter the self-help landscape with the power of the snakes.

We do not need control. We need some relief. It is as unique as we are.

Any kind of 'self-care' that feels more like a chore than a step toward freedom is bound to send you ricocheting blindly back to your old 'bad' habits.

I was broken-hearted over an ex-boyfriend when I was a personal trainer. I worked hard every day to make my heart strong. I dragged myself out of bed and worked out at the gym for an hour each morning before getting a temp job.

As time went on, the routine began to feel like a trap. He owned my mornings even after he left. I was faced with a choice: stick with a tired routine, give up and risk failure, or honor it and move on to something new.

I went hiking after choosing the latter.

I ate bowls of homemade cookie dough and large pizzas at night. It felt like a different kind of relief to have food. I had struggled with eating and body image for many years, and I knew nothing good came of trying to control myself. I always ended up swinging from the ceiling fan with a box of Krispy Kreme howling, because rules were made to be broken. Buzzkill, how do you like this?

I was faced with a choice, either to keep bingeing and hate myself for it, or to explore alternative ways to get nightly relief.

I couldn't decide. I knew I didn't want to hate myself, but the other two choices left me stumped. Is the food making me feel good enough to justify the pain of acid reflux? Maybe. The high of a sheet cake and a fork was something I really liked. If there were other ways to feel good at night, what would it be like?

In order to investigate, I needed to binge. I had to get out of my shell. I had to dig into the old habits for a while to figure out what they were. I ate for the pure fun of it, to find out how the entire bowl of cookie dough felt in my body.

It didn't feel good to stuff myself every night. It didn't feel good to abuse myself at the gym in the name of an ex-boyfriend. These truths are true.

Many of my clients were 10 or 20 years older than me. I had people with three kids and no others. I had attorneys, gardeners and designers who all wanted to know how to change their bad habits.

They wanted to know the answers. A personal trainer with a history of depression and eating disorders. I didn't have answers to their questions yet, but I was determined to find them.

Most people resent diet and fitness rules. It is usually a quiet rebellion. They didn't tell me to piss off if I prescribed a plan for them. They printed it out after taking it home. They put it on the wall or fridge and blamed themselves for not following through. The paper was not relevant at the end of the day. Relief did.

We didn't need rules. The best place to find data was in the habits themselves. They have a lot to teach us, but we can't hear the messages while demonizing ourselves.

My clients and I didn’t need rules. We needed visceral, reliable, unbiased data, and the best place to find it was in the 'bad' habits themselves.

It can feel like a free fall if you let go of control. It's frightening. If I took away the rules about what I could or couldn't do, I would sit around and eat everything in sight. I did some of that, but mostly I just did what I was doing before, and that was evidence for my investigation.

Each night I made my own decision. I didn't have to make a declaration the day before or pretend I knew in advance what I was going to do. Over time, the impulse to overindulge disappeared as deprivation was nowhere on the horizon. bingeing was no longer necessary because I had the authority to eat what I wanted the next day, even if I ate more than I wanted.

There are a lot of sweet ways to get relief that don't have to do with acid reflux.

They fight bitterly with impulses they need to control.

She apologized when she came back a week later. She didn't complete the mission. She was satisfied with a half or a third of the ice cream that was coming the next night. She let her body do the talking and discovered that she did, in fact, like ice cream, but not as frantic as she thought. The battle over ice cream was over when she realized that. She had taken its fuel.

A bad habit is just a way to cope. It's a hit of pleasure in exchange for long-term consequences, but trying to conquer our desires in a wave of chronic stress is ill-advised.

Control isn't the answer; exploration is a life-long scavenger hunt to enrich our quality of life.

I'm not interested in a life without flexibility. Bad habits can be fun if they add up to something worth changing. I head back into the bad habit a few more times until the desire for something new is clear.

Relief is just around the bend at the intersection of health and pleasure.

Sarah Hays Coomer is a health and wellbeing coach and author, and she writes a column for Forbes called Hey, Health Coach. She has contributed to a number of publications. Her books include The Habit Trip, Physical Disobedience, and Lightness of Body and Mind. You can find her on the internet at www.SarahHays Coomer.com.

.

Do you want your story to be published on HuffPost? Send us a pitch if you know what we're looking for.

The article was originally on HuffPost.

More From HuffPost Personal...

  • Dressed in baggy T-shirts and jeans, with bandanas and wraparound sunglasses only partially obscuring their intricate tattoos, Thais can now be seen on the sweaty streets of Bangkok celebrating a fusion of their own and Chicano culture each weekend. The Thai interpretation of the Chicano movement in the US is more focused on its aesthetic.

  • Daffodils, iris and tulips can be found at garden centers.

  • The most unlikely coincidences of all time don't appear in the history books.

  • She is supposed to do whatever you say and listen to your instructions. You agreed to this! This is the voice of the conman at the heart of Bad vegan, the wild new true-crime series that is being talked about.

  • 23 years ago, I married my best friend and it is working out beautifully, said Michael McKean in a statement.

  • The reporter for Hromadske was kidnapped in the occupied port city of Berdyansk.

  • AdTheDaddest
    • Why this Ad?
    • Go ad-free*

    Some of the best company responses will be seen on social media.

  • Georgia has recently been found with the Heartland virus, a deadly illness transmitted by lone star ticks. Experts say it could be more common than people think.

  • We have had to break up with a beloved TV series over and over again in recent years, not because the content of the shows in question had changed, but because of the backstage scandals that made it impossible to watch.

  • A healthy diet can help with reversing diabetes.

  • AdPost Fun
    • Why this Ad?
    • Go ad-free*

    The only ones who can defeat the legendary Thanos are the superhero and villains of the Marvel universe.

  • There are a few ways that you can cut down on household costs until prices return to normal.

  • Millions of baby boomers are caring for an aging parent, whether helping with shopping or as primary caregivers. How can they not be stressed?

  • The Shiba Inu token has proved to be wrong a few times. The price of the meme was 49,000,000% higher than anyone expected. To get there, the coin needs to rise by another 4,000,000% on top of what it already accomplished.

  • AdLivingly
    • Why this Ad?
    • Go ad-free*

    There are many different types of movies made these days, including a sequel, a remake, a soft reboot, and a spin-off.

  • Eva Longoria's makeup artist, Elan Bongiorno, shared her top beauty tip for women over 40: use primer. She says it helps her makeup last longer.

  • The new venture is a collaboration between Sony Pictures Entertainment and Merlin Entertainment. Jumanji is a multi-territory exclusive, meaning you will only be able to see it at the parks. It will be called Jumanji - the Adventure and is described as a dark ride for adventure lovers of all ages.

  • I'm a big texter. I like to vent about my work and share my thoughts on the news. It helps me get through the day. My long-term boyfriend is not a texter.

  • The movies did not hit the mark.

  • Every day is a blessing. On her 40th birthday, the author wrote that life is to be lived.

  • The 33rd Annual Producers Guild Awards were held in Los Angeles at the Fairmont Century Plaza Hotel.

  • Who doesn't want to live longer? Humans have a longer lifespan than most other animals. There might be a way to temporarily hold on to life even if our bodies can't hold up anymore. Maybe sleep is the answer we're looking for in the quest for eternal life, not literally, but adding some years might at least feel like living forever. Exce.

  • AdFar & Wide
    • Why this Ad?
    • Go ad-free*

    Have you ever seen a map that made you laugh? The maps we found were hilarious.

  • We are outside, y'all.

  • Northwest Florida Daily News

    A dog with back pain will avoid walking.

  • It is time to buy your zeppoles. St. Joseph's Day is on March 19 and here is a list of bakeries to get yours.