The first exoplanets were discovered in 1992. They found a pair of them in the vicinity of a pulsar. The third planet was discovered two years later.

A team of astronomer are trying to find 800 known pulsars for exoplanets.

The Jodrell Bank Centre for Manchester has a team of astronomer. A group at Jodrell Bank works on time-domain astrophysics. 800 pulsars are monitored by Jodrell Bank as part of their work.

Iuliana Nitu is the first author of a paper titled "A search for planetary companions around 800 pulsars from the Jodrell Bank pulsar timing programme".

The first pulsar was discovered by an astronomer from Northern Ireland. It took them a while to figure out what they were. There was a lot of speculation about alien sources, but once other pulsars were discovered, it became clear they were naturally-occurring objects.

The beams of radiation from the poles of a pulsar are very strong. When one of the poles is pointed at Earth, we can see it. There are radio, visible light, x-rays, and even gamma rays. The beam is visible as a pulsar rotates, but it is invisible for a short time. The intervals are more precise than an atomic clock, and that makes them useful for astronomy.

They are ideal for searching for planets around them. The pulsar is moving back and forth because of a slight variation in their timing. One or more planets could be tugging on it. The pulsar timing method is used to look for exoplanets.

The transit method is the most common method of looking for planets. It involves looking for dips in the star's light. If a dip in the starlight is repeated regularly, it is evidence of a planet transiting in front of the star. Most exoplanets are found with this method, although follow-up measurements with other methods are often used to confirm a planet's presence.

The transit method has an inherent selection bias. It is easier to detect large planets because they block more light. It is easier to find planets that are close to their stars because they are more likely to cause dips in starlight.

This illustration shows a pulsar with its magnetic field lines shown in blue. The beams emitting from the poles are what washes over our detectors as the dead star spins. Image Credit: NASA
This illustration shows a pulsar with its magnetic field lines shown in blue. The beams emitting from the poles are what washes over our detectors as the dead star spins. Image Credit: NASA

The timing of pulsar is different. Small planets can signal their presence by tugging on pulsars. The planets detected around PSR B1257+12 were smaller than most exoplanets found with the transit method. The smallest of the three was less than 1 Earth mass. The smallest exoplanet ever found was 80% of Earth's size.

This new effort to find exoplanets is different from other planet-hunting efforts. This is not a new survey or monitoring program. The data used in this work is from the Jodrell Bank pulsar timing database.

Is there a chance of finding more exoplanets around pulsars? The authors write that the rarity of systems like that of PSR B1257+12 may be due to the extreme conditions in which they form.

There are two types of stars, the neutron stars and the calamitous ones. They are between 10 and 25 solar mass stars. At the end of their lives of regular fusion, these stars explode as supernovae and then collapse into ultra-dense neutron stars made of neutron degenerate matter. It is highly unlikely that any planet could survive that.

Artist’s impression of a supernova. Credit: NASA

Is it possible that planets could form after the supernova? Maybe. The authors explain a scenario in which a planet forms around a pair of stars and is captured by a neutron star after a collision. The planet could have survived the evolution of the initial system towards a neutron star system.

They write that the resulting system would consist of a normal pulsar with planetary companions in eccentric circles. It would require a very good environment for planets to survive.

A second scenario is possible. When a supernova explodes, it expels an enormous amount of material, which is blasted out into space at high speed. Some of the matter may not escape the remaining star's gravity. The planets form via accretion. The authors say that a normal pulsar, surrounded by relatively small mass planets, is expected.

A third scenario is1-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-65561-6556 A planet is a remnant of a star in a pair of stars. One of the stars can cause the other to partially evaporate. The remnant core is made of diamonds.

There are many planet-forming possibilities around pulsars. There are a lot of proposed formation paths of planets around pulsars, and therefore large-scale searches of planetary-mass companions and their orbital.

There are still problems despite the precision of the timing. The detection of planets around pulsars is limited by the presence of a long-term red noise. The authors write that this presents a further challenge in searching for planetary companions as it can not only mask signatures but also mimic them.

The team had to model the effect a planet has on a pulsar. When a pulsar is part of a system with a star or planet, it revolves around the center of the system, moving with respect to the observer on Earth. There is a slight delay in the signal reaching Earth. The delay is called a Rømer delay.

This is an illustration of the binary pulsar J0737-3039. Most binary pulsars are pulsars paired with a planet or a neutron star, but J0737-3039 is a pair of pulsars. Image Credit: By Michael Kramer (Jodrell Bank Observatory, University of Manchester), Attribution, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=827204
This is an illustration of the binary pulsar J0737-3039. Most binary pulsars are pulsars paired with a planet or a neutron star, but J0737-3039 is a pair of pulsars. Image Credit: By Michael Kramer (Jodrell Bank Observatory, University of Manchester), Attribution, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=827204

The team of researchers used many factors to develop their method. Limits are put on the projected mass of any planetary companions, which can be as low as 1/100th of the mass of the Moon.

The researchers said that their approach was well-suited for a systematic search of planets around pulsars, for placing limits on the mass of any circling bodies, and for inferring statistically significant properties of the population of these planets.

What did they find?

The team says that two-thirds of the pulsars are not likely to host any other people. It is a benchmark for pulsar planet systems.

There is one caveat to these results, and that is the fact that the smaller planet in this system would be hidden in most of the sample.

Some of the pulsars in the sample did show some signs, but they weren't planets. The team says that the severe magnetosphere around pulsars can cause irregular periodicities.

It appears that pulsar planets are very rare. The most likely candidate for planets is a single pulsar in the 800.

The authors wrote that the initial analysis of PSR J2007+3120 revealed an oscillation consistent with a planetary companion. The evidence for the second planet is not as strong as it could be.

The team did not find many planets. Only one of the 800 pulsars has strong evidence of planets. What does this tell us about the universe? It shows how unusual the PSR B1257+12 system is.

“We therefore confirm the hypothesis that the formation of planets around pulsars is rare, and PSR B1257+12 is a special case.”

From “A search for planetary companions around 800 pulsars from the Jodrell

Bank pulsar timing programme” by Nitu et al. 2022.

The team confirms that PSR B1257+12 has an unusual formation mechanism, placing an upper bound of 2.5% of similar planets.

Artist's impression of the planets orbiting PSR B1257+12. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/R. Hurt (SSC)
Artist’s impression of the planets orbiting PSR B1257+12. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/R. Hurt (SSC)

They can't rule out a population of smaller planets. The timing noise in most pulsars means that we can't rule out a large number of tiny planets.

They conclude that the formation of planets around pulsars is rare, and that PSR B1257+12 is a special case. It is the only pulsar that can host Earth-size planets.

Eliminating the noise in the signal might be possible as technology improves. This effort won't be the final word.

Habitability is extremely unlikely. The region is very cold. Any planets in the vicinity could be affected by the magnetic fields. There is no fusion taking place because pulsars are neutron stars. Cinders can still be extremely hot, but they are little more than cinders. The blasted remnants of a pulsar's stellar companion can be found on some of the planets around them. Others are captured.

The study was not about habitability. It is meant to investigate some of the most unusual objects in the Universe. Is it possible that these end-state stars are made of degenerate neutron matter, which could cause extreme magnetic fields on host planets?

Not very often.

More: