The $1.75 trillion spending plan of the Democrats includes housing aid but is unlikely to address the affordability crisis.
Although the package is expected to create 1,000,000 homes, estimates of the shortage range from 6.8 million to 6.9 million.
The unveiling of the plan comes amid record home prices and delays by builders to increase supply.
A daily selection of top stories, based on your reading preferences, is available to you. Loading Click Sign up to receive marketing emails and other offers from Insider.
The Democrats' huge spending package includes historic investments to solve the housing shortage. It's likely not enough, according to the math.
As Democrats struggle to pass their legislative agenda, President Joe Biden presented the latest version his Build Back Better plan. The plan includes the goal to build 1 million homes. Experts say that the construction boom could need to be seven times bigger.
The estimates of the national shortage vary greatly. Freddie Mac stated in May that the nation needed 3.8 million homes by 2020. The National Association of Realtors predicted in June that the market gap is closer to 6.8 millions homes, even after taking into account yearly demolitions.
Major programs such as universal preschool and tax breaks for clean-energy are included in the current plan. The plan also includes $150 billion in housing assistance. These funds are needed as the US sees home prices rise and buyers face a shortage of homes. However, this sum is lower than the $359 billion in the original proposal.
The projected impact of the framework has been also reduced. The original framework was designed to create more homes than the new one, which is twice what it now targets.
Even if the package gets approved, the housing shortage is likely to continue. The country has been left with too many homes over the years due to underbuilding, particularly as millennials reach their peak homebuying age and drive up demand.
Redfin chief economist Daryl Fairweather tweeted that "I still don't understand how the BBB plan can help the housing shortage."
Housing support is also in short supply
The $1.75 trillion proposal was the result of weeks of negotiations with Senate Democrats Joe Manchin, Kyrsten Sinema and other centrist Senate Democrats, who both rejected the initial $3.5 billion price tag.
The provisions were also reduced to reduce funding for housing support programs. The bill retains funding for programs such as the Housing Trust Fund, public housing and rental vouchers, but it has less. Experts are less hopeful that the cuts will be able to address the affordable-housing crisis when taken together.
Fairweather stated to Insider that while housing aid can help people in the short-term, it does not solve the problem of too many homes. "Without more homes the market price of homes will continue to rise."
Democrats are not only trying to fill this gap with the Build Back Better plan. Biden announced a series of regulatory changes in September which is expected to help create 100,000 homes over the next three-years. This plan is one of the few Biden initiatives that can be taken without congressional support. However, it pales in comparison with the complete shortage.
People who were hoping that builders would come to their rescue will likely be disappointed. According to the NAR, US housing starts must reach an annual rate in excess of 2 million annually to alleviate the shortage. But starts fell slightly to 1.55million in September. Economists at Goldman Sachs stated earlier in October that construction should pick up next year but that even then, starts will only reach an annual pace of 1.65million.
Logan Mohtashami (lead analyst at HousingWire), told Insider in October that builders don't care much about the existing-homesales market or the housing shortage. They'll always be slow and steady. People want an oversupplied marketplace, which we don't have in America.