Why America has 8.4 million unemployed when there are 10 million job openings

The economic recovery is characterized by a mystery: While there are 10 million job opportunities, more than 8.4 millions people are actively seeking work.
In some ways, the job market is reminiscent of a boom-time environment. Many businesses complain that they don't have enough workers. Pay is increasing rapidly and customers are often greeted by "please be patient" signs in restaurants and stores.

Subscribe to The Post Most newsletter to receive the latest and most interesting stories from The Washington Post.

The nation is still suffering from a deadly pandemic, with covid-19 hospitalizations at their highest levels since January. With only 235,000 new jobs in August, the surge is again weighing on labor markets. The number of jobs is still 5 million lower than before the pandemic. This is due to ongoing problems such as child care, which has seen some day cares and schools close down because of outbreaks.

It's difficult to know what's going on, and what's likely to happen next.

Video: Why some Americans are reluctant to return to work

The employment crisis will reach an inflection point this weekend as many unemployed people lose $300 per week in federal weekly benefits, and millions of self-employed and gig workers lose their unemployment aid completely. Although some people anticipate a surge of job seekers in 22 states, which have already eliminated those benefits, workers did not return to their jobs in the 22 other states.

There is an economic reallocation taking place that is prompting a "Great Review" of American work from both the employee and employer perspectives. Workers are choosing where and how they work. This is a personal decision for some. People have been changed by the pandemic, all of the anxiety, lockdowns, and time spent at home. Some people want to work remotely for life. Some people want to spend more quality time with their families. Others want a more fulfilling or flexible career. This is the "you only have one chance" mentality. Companies are increasing automation, redoing entire supply chains, and reorganizing office setups.

Continue the story

This year's reassessment has been seen in every sphere of the labor market. People make different choices about work than before the pandemic. The highest number of resignations ever recorded - an increase of 13 percent over prepandemic levels. There are now 4.9 million people who are not working or searching for work, compared to before the pandemic. The pandemic saw a rise in retirements, with more than 2,000,000 people retiring. The biggest increase in business applications in recent years has been due to a surge in entrepreneurship.

Ben Bernanke was the Federal Reserve Chair from 2006 to 2014. "We are relocating where and how we want work." People are trying to determine what their best options and where they want.

It's not surprising that many of the job opportunities right now aren't in the same professions or locations as those who worked before the pandemic.

There is a huge mismatch between the number of job openings in a particular industry and the number of people who were employed there before the pandemic. There are almost 3.5 million jobs available in the hospitality industry, and less than 1.5 million people who have been unemployed since their last job was in this sector.

Similar mismatches have been observed in education and healthcare services. There are almost twice as many job opportunities than there are people who worked in this sector in the past.

According to Labor Department data, educators and heath care workers have been leaving their jobs at an unprecedented rate in recent months. This is a trend that dates back to 2002.

Cindy Lehnhoff (36-year veteran in the child care industry, currently head of the National Child Care Association), said, "This is usually the time of year that we recruit for the next school year. But we literally can't have enough candidates and we see tenured people leaving." "If you find one candidate who is good, there will be 10 other people who contact that person." It's a crisis. It's impossible to work without child care."

Lehnhoff helped a Virginia child care center recruit more staff. Their infant room is still closed because they don’t have enough staff. A nearby elementary school recently hired one of their veteran workers. Lehnhoff looked through the Indeed.com job portal while she was speaking with The Washington Post. There were more than 2000 job postings in Fairfax County, Va. for child care assistants. They were paid between $12 and $13 an hour, which is a little less than the prices at nearby restaurants and retail shops.

Labor Department data shows that most industries offer more job opportunities than those with previous experience in the sector. This is a far different situation from the Great Recession when there were many more job openings than the available jobs in all sectors. Companies may have to train workers or entice them to change careers. This process is usually slower in areas that require special licenses.

Although companies claim they are struggling for workers, many people who aren't employed say they are having difficulty getting hired, particularly if they haven’t worked in a year.

Brandon Harvey, a forklift driver, and his wife worked in an Atlanta warehouse that was closed during the pandemic. It never reopened. Harvey, 33, spent months searching for work online and driving around South Fullerton. Harvey submitted many applications, but he never received a call back.

Harvey stated that employers were hesitant to offer you a job right now, especially if you haven’t worked in a while. This was during a particularly frustrating summer.

Harvey and his wife were behind on their rent. Their landlord wanted them to be evicted. Their two children, a 13-year-old and a toddler, were difficult to keep positive. Harvey was able to find $10-$12 an hour jobs in spring and summer but that wasn't enough to support his family. Before the pandemic, Harvey made $17.

"I was not going to work for $10 an hour or $12 an hr." Harvey stated that this was not going to make any difference.

He had spent months job hunting and was finally offered a $21 per hour job in a warehouse of a major retailer. He is expected to begin in September 4.

In an effort to attract more people back into work, companies across the economy are increasing their pay rates at an alarming rate. Although it has helped, the reallocation and pandemic pains remain significant obstacles.

The average rank-and-file worker's pay has increased by 2.8 percent over the past five month, excluding the pandemic. This is the highest rate of growth since 1981.

The wage battle for lower-paid jobs has been fierce, particularly since many ex-service sector workers claim they won't be returning to work due to their long hours, exhausting work, and increased exposure to the disease.

Pay is up 8.8% for nonmanagerial workers in the restaurant-and-hospitality sector and 6.1% for warehouse workers in the past five months. This seems to be helping workers return. Nearly half of the 3.1 million new jobs since March are in hospitality. However, hiring in this sector stagnated in August due to the rise in delta variant.

Many Americans are being forced into changing careers, regardless of whether or not they wish. The pandemic has been around for longer than anyone anticipated, and the number of long-term unemployed has increased. Around 40% of the 3.2 million currently unemployed have been out of work for at least six months.

Research, particularly after the Great Recession, has shown that these workers have a harder time returning to work. Hiring managers doubt that these workers have the skills they need. Often, previous employers and jobs are gone. This forces job seekers to send out their resumes online, without having any personal connections.

"People who are unemployed for a short period of time can get jobs very quickly," is a well-known fact in labor economics. Peter Ganong, an assistant professor of economics at University of Chicago's Harris School of Public Policy, said that people who have been unemployed for a while have a harder job finding a job.

Many long-term unemployed people have been so discouraged they are now planning to retire earlier than expected.

Annie Farley, Hutchinson (Kan.), said that she didn't intend to retire before she was 63. However, she recently applied for Social Security because she no longer received any unemployment benefits. She is struggling to pay for basic necessities. She cannot afford to fix her car in order to commute to work.

Farley was an embroidery worker for many years, managing orders and running the machines. But she was fired at the outbreak of the pandemic. Farley had hoped that she would be able to return in the summer, but her employer had already replaced her with a younger worker who was cheaper.

It's been very difficult. Farley, who cares for her two grandchildren, said that she's missed my credit card payments and will likely have to enter into a pay agreement. "It feels as if there are a million people applying to two positions around here."

Economists claim that overall employment is actually rising at an amazing rate. The recovery of more than 75 percent are faster than anyone expected a year ago. According to private forecasters, all jobs could be recovered by the middle to late of 2022. This is a two-year rebound compared to the six-plus year period it took for the labor markets to recover after the Great Recession.

Jerome H. Powell, Federal Reserve Chair, recently stated that it has been a "vigorous, but uneven recovery". Black and Hispanic women continue to suffer the most, along with Americans without college degrees.

It is apparent in the state's performance that there has been a uneven recovery. The labor market in some parts of the country is flourishing. In Idaho and Utah, the labor market is booming. There was a lot of recovery in employment months ago and unemployment rates at 2.6 and 3% respectively. Other states are still reeling. Hawaii still has 12 percent unemployment, New York still has 9%, Nevada, Alaska, and other tourism-dependent countries are struggling amid rapidly-expanding covid-19 varieties.

As more workers stay at home, it has meant that urban centers in San Francisco and Washington D.C. are struggling to recover. These office workers have lost the support of local shops and restaurants, particularly as bellwether employers like Google, Amazon, Apple, and Facebook delay openings until January. The Washington Post is owned by Jeff Bezos, Amazon founder. Currently, workers are most needed in suburban areas. There, housing costs have soared, making it hard for low-wage workers who want to live there.

The labor market's gaps are becoming smaller as the recovery progresses. Half of all jobs in high-contact sectors like movie theaters and buffets are still vacant. However, other industries that were more severely affected by the crisis in the beginning, such as RV dealers and carwashes have made a complete comeback thanks to record consumer spending.

Some industries, like delivery services, mortgage lenders and breakfast-cereal producers, seemed to have survived the crisis without losing jobs. They now have 10 to 20 percent more employees today than they had in February 2020.

Many business leaders and the White House hope that a combination of higher vaccination rates, lower unemployment benefits, and more time will help more Americans find new jobs - and be more excited about them.

Sarah Henrie, 39 years old, is from San Francisco Bay. She lost her job as a corporate executive at Bloomingdales in June 2020. It was difficult to find work in her field of expertise, international marketing and tourism. She was initially shocked when she found herself without a job for the first time in her professional career.

After her daughter's birth, she decided that she wanted to have a flexible career. She is about to take the California real estate exam. If everything goes according to plan, she will begin working as a realtor with her brother early next year.

Henrie stated, "It has been a wild year and we are still sort of navigating." Real estate is flexible. You don't have to commute and go into an office. It will allow me to work, and I'll be able spend more time with my child than I would if I was in my previous role.

This great reallocation is possible only if some workers aren’t left behind.

Similar Content

The summer immediately preceding 9/11

Kenneth Feinberg was asked by the FBI to do something unimaginable after 9/11: To assign a value for each person who died that day

George W. Bush's wars have ended, but he has retreated some time ago