The 'fetal heartbeat' that defines Texas' new abortion laws doesn't exist, says doctors

Texas's new, draconian abortion ban hinges on the time that a fetal beat forms -- at six weeks.
Doctors say that a heartbeat is not present after 6 weeks.

Six-week-old fetus does not have a heart, so the sound of the thumping comes from the machine.

Insider Healthcare: Get the latest news and analysis in healthcare Loading Click to sign up for marketing emails from Insider and other partners. You also agree to our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy

Texas has recently passed new laws that prohibit abortions after six weeks. This is the time when a "fetal beat" appears and most people are aware they are pregnant.

Doctors are now claiming that the "fetal pulse" is not a valid medical point in fetal development. This casts doubt on the Fetal Heartbeat Bill's credibility.

The opening and closing of heart valves causes human heartbeats to produce a thumpthump sound.

NPR spoke with Dr. Nisha verma, an OB/GYN who specializes on abortion care and works at American College of Obstetricians and Gynologists. She said that the heartbeat is not present in 6-week-old fetuses.

She stated that at six weeks gestation those valves didn't exist.

These valves take between 9-10 weeks to form.

"The ultrasound shows that the flickering we see is electrical activity. The sound you hear is actually produced by the ultrasound machine. Dr. Verma also added.

NPR was also informed by Dr. Jennifer Kerns who is an OB-GYN, and associate professor at University of California, San Francisco. She said that the noise is not a sign of a functioning heart or functional cardiovascular system.

Dr. Kerns said that doctors use this term to simplify complex medical discussions with patients. It is similar to the term "tummy ache", rather than "gastroenteritis", or "dizzy spell" instead of "vertigo". However, it should not be used for making laws.

The correct term is also an embryo at six weeks after conception.

Kern explained to NPR that "fetus" might have a different appeal than "embryo". Kern said that "fetus" evokes images that resemble a baby and that it is better to use this term. "Embryos, on the other hand, may be more difficult for people to identify with, because they don't look like babies. These terms are intentionally used in these laws and can also be misleading.

According to the Guttmacher Institute, a number of laws have been created to restrict abortion access based on the false notion that fetal heartbeats are present. However, the Texas law is the most recent to take effect.

Anyone who legally needs an abortion in Texas must drive more than 200 miles.

Data shows that abortion bans, as Texas's new law is, do not prevent abortions. They are just legal and safe. Amnesty International states.

A Guttmacher Institute study found that abortion rates in countries that ban abortions are actually higher.