Further Reading FDA approves Pfizers' COVID-19 vaccine. Now called Comirnaty formal approval, the vaccine for Covid-19 was developed by Pfizer and BioNTech. It is possible that you have already received a dose. Millions of Americans have. The new designation was not just a formality. It is now official, President Joe Biden announced. In the same speech, President Joe Biden said: "If you are a business leader or a leader of a non-profit organization, a state leader or a local leader who has been waiting to get full FDA approval to require vaccinations then I urge you to now do that.
A lot of people got their shots almost immediately. Vaccines can be safe, effective and cost-free, but around 30% of Americans still have not received their shots. The sticks are here, the carrots have failed. They might even be able stop the fourth wave in the Covid pandemic in America if they do it right.
The Pfizer drug, like the other vaccines available under EUA is extremely effective at keeping people from getting sick with Covid. It is clear that this alone won't be enough. There are more than 100,000 people with Covid in the US, the highest number since January. Incentives like cash or prizes have been used by states, localities, as well as businesses to get people to do what is best for them. This is called a "nudge" in behavioral economics. These nudges did not change the momentum in states that have low vaccine uptake. Now it's time to mandate. Get ready to push if you're among the 30% of Americans who haven't had their vaccines yet.
The Pentagon is the most pushy of all. The Department of Defense announced immediately that it would add Covid-19 vaccines, to the already-extended list of vaccines required for servicemembers. California's UC system, which is home to many large universities, already has mandates. However, more schools are joining: Ohio State University, University of Michigan and University of Minnesota. Mandates were placed on city workforces in Los Angeles, Chicago, and other areas. At her inauguration, the new governor of New York stated that she would also institute them. New York City implemented them for teachers in public schools and the NYPD. The open letter was signed by nearly every major medical and healthcare professional association. In late July, the influential American Medical Association reiterated its position. Even Goldman Sachs' hardcore capitalists won't allow anyone to enter their offices without proof of shot. Three examples are all that is required to create a trend in journalism. They were there, I believe.
This may sound like jackbootery, but the history of American public policy and health law shows otherwise. Vaccine mandates, and other rules restricting personal behavior for the sake of societal wellbeing, are extremely legal. Ask Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett. She reaffirmed this notion two weeks ago with a terse "not-gonna-happen" response to a lawsuit filed by students at Indiana University regarding their vaccine mandate. Barrett's firm nope supported an appeals court ruling that was in turn based upon Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905 Supreme Court decision) which gave permission for smallpox vaccinations and other public health regulations. By the way, most Americans support vaccine mandates. Of course, they are divided along political lines. A study from this summer found that elite Republicans could be more forceful in their support for vaccines. This is not just a personal choice. Ask your doctor to make that happen, but it would increase the number of people who plan to get vaccinated by up to 7 percent. No one has the right to be unmasked or unvaccinated in a crowd. According to Lawrence Gostin (a Georgetown University public health policy expert), Americans don't have the right to spread an infectious disease to others.
Advertisement
It is important to note that FDA approval was not required for a mandate. However, it turned out to suffice. Local governments, schools, businesses, and other entities that sought to avoid backlash from the FDA over experimental vaccines now see a brighter future. This might have been a feint. Texas Governor Greg Abbott's anti-mandate policy used the EUA. However, it was changed after approval to include any Covid-19 vaccine. Gostin says they were concerned about litigation, employee perceptions, and public perception. In the next few weeks, we will see a slew of universities and companies following their lead.
But, what is the most important thing about vaccine mandates? They work, according to Saad Omer (director of Yale Institute for Global Health) and an expert on vaccine acceptance. The evidence is largely based on childhood vaccinations. It comes from influenza vaccines for health care workers. This shows that mandating is effective. This will take you from 70 to 80 percent to 90 percent or 95 percent.
All public schools in the US require children to present proof of vaccination against different illnesses. Different states allow for different levels of opt-outs. These requirements led to an 18% increase in overall vaccination rates, according to one analysis. Omer and his coworkers also found that pertussis rates were higher in states where exemptions were easier for children. Pertussis is a childhood disease with a widely-available vaccine. It could get worse: parents are fined in Australia for failing to give their children vaccines and parents are sent to prison in Uganda.
But there's a catch. You have to follow mandates exactly. One reason is that mandate policies that are too harsh can lead to anti-vaccine protests. The problem is that not all vaccines are created equal. There are many reasons why people may not be vaccinated. Some people have philosophical or political disagreements. Some people don't believe in vaccines or subscribe to conspiracy theories. A Civiqs poll found that 91 percent of Democrats and 64 percent of Independents have had their vaccines administered. Only 53 percent of Republicans have. According to another Kaiser Foundation poll, 5 percent of these Republicans believe that the only way they would get vaccinated again is if it was necessary. It's so nice to meet you! It's now. You are welcome!
Some people aren't vaccinated due to forces beyond their control. Covid-19 has impacted certain groups, particularly those with lower socioeconomic status and people of colour. These people are at the heart of many Venn overlaps. They are more likely than others to have health issues that could make Covid infection fatal, less likely have access to medical care, more likely be in high-risk occupations with lots of exposure, less likely have access to good internet access, and more likely have jobs that pay per hour and don't allow sick leave. It can be difficult to think of getting vaccinated if all this is happening. The vaccine mandates could make certain areas unaccessible, such as Black people.
The answer is: You shouldn't. Gostin states that you shouldn't force someone to get vaccinated if they are unable to do so. You can bring the vaccine to work or campus. Access and equity must be your main focus.
These are policy issues that can be fixed. Goldman Sachs has the resources to set up an in-house vaccine clinic. Federal government could make it illegal for someone to take vaccine-related leave, or pay compensation for lost wages like with jury duty, as President Biden suggested. Gostin states that equity is the only valid objection to mandates. It's about being fair, equitable and compassionate and not demeaning people who have not been vaccinated. This is not a way to create a social divide in America. Vaccination mandates and vaccinations are neutral tools in the public health system. They do not penalize those who aren't vaccinated.
Advertisement
Mandates can only do what they are supposed to. They require additional policies that support them. In an article published in the New England Journal of Medicine, Omer, Michelle Mello of Stanford and Ross Silverman of Indiana University said that when vaccines against Covid were only a twinkle in the eyes of a hypodermic needle, more than half of Americans stated they would not get a vaccine if one became available. The basic idea was that a mandate will not work unless there is enough vaccine (check), and evidence of safety has been well-communicated. The government has removed any financial or logistical obstacles and voluntary uptake is not preventing spread (super check). This varies from one state to the next, and even from one business to another. Omer states that these criteria are not being met right now for the general population. They have been met for university students, health care workers and a large number of employers.
Equity might not be as problematic as people think. Although there were early signs of resistance to the vaccine, minorities are now able to take up Covid vaccines at around 60 percent. However, this varies from one region to another. Around 15 percent of whites and blacks say they would never get the vaccine. It is closer to 11 percent for Hispanics. The opposite may be true, despite all the concern that people might quit their jobs if they are required to get vaccinated. My research showed that employees are more likely to quit if there is no vaccine mandate than if there were. Gostin states that many people forget the other side of the coin. People who want safety at school and work far outnumber those who oppose it. The highest percentage of African Americans who said that they would quit if there wasn't a mandate was found in the study.
Although opposition to mandates may initially appear strong, it is important to not underestimate its strength. The head of the Chicago police officers union stated that the mandate had lit a fire under the members because they didn't want to be forced to. France's imposition of a wide vaccine mandate was met by massive protests. 1.3 million people signed up for their shots the first day.
This is what United Airlines seems to be doing. In January, the CEO stated that he would mandate vaccinations for all 67,000 employees of United Airlines. He was expecting resistance. (All the major US airlines have not implemented vaccine mandates. Delta requires vaccinations. However, employees can opt out by paying a small fine. This is basically covering the additional insurance. When you face situations like this, you will typically have a majority who agree with your position and then a small minority who strongly and passionately disagree with you. Josh Earnest is chief communications officer at United. Here's the punchline. This became apparent after we announced the announcement. While there are a few people who strongly oppose the requirement, there is a larger group of employees who support it enthusiastically.
This was possible because United had prepared the groundwork. United established vaccination clinics at airports with large numbers of workers. The company distributed educational materials about vaccines. It met with unions representing pilots and flight attendants. United will not suffer, but that does not mean it won't. Airlines already have staffing problems significant enough to disrupt flight schedules. It would be a terrible thing to lose pilots due to vaccines. Earnest states that it is too early to know how much vaccine hesitancy, objection or how large a group this is. We won't know until September's deadline, which will occur in September.
The internal tension that exists between vocal opponents and larger groups that support mandates is an example of another kind of equity issue. According to Govind Persad (a professor of health law and policy at the University of Denver), people who are less fortunate or are members of minorities that are subject to discrimination are the ones most at risk of being denied mandates. Many people feel that mandates are unfair because they treat people differently. The problem is that mandates are also inequitable. This is evident when you consider the fact that Covid's fourth wave is passing through certain regions of the US.
This story first appeared on wired.com
