Tesla’s Electric Monster Truck Complicates Elon Musk’s Climate Commitment

A fundamental shift in focus for the electric vehicle maker that started much earlier, obscures a fundamental shift in focus for the electric vehicle maker that started much earlier. From the "secret master plan" goal set by Musk in 2006 to lead a transition to climate-friendly, affordable electric vehicles for everyone--ideally powered by solar energy--Tesla has become the top maker of high-powered, resource-gobbling EV priced far beyond the reach of

Musk is going to double down on that strategy. The Cybetruck arrives at that time. The American pickup is the top-selling class of U.S. vehicle, but it looks a lot like a futuristic military vehicle. The company hasn't provided many details about its proportions, though it's expected to be available with a 200 kilowatt hour or larger battery, twice the size ofTesla's current biggest pack, and may weigh in at 8,500 pounds. None of the company's models has ever sold at the low end of Musk's predictions. The price with taxes may be $100,000 for a heavy truck with features such as autopilot and full-self driving.

While there may be environmental benefits from driving a Cybertruck instead of a heavy-duty gasoline or diesel pickup from Ford or General GM, the large amount of energy, aluminum and mined materials needed to build it and an initial price that is likely to be, are likely to be the main reasons While those mined battery materials might eliminate tailpipe emissions, they can also have environmental harms, such as pollution from mining scraps and chemicals, and human costs. In August, the board persuaded shareholders to vote against a proposition requiring more detailed reporting on child labor, despite the fact that the annual environmental impact report says it requires suppliers to adhere to strict ethical guidelines.

As the once disruptive company matures, Musk is focusing on boosting sales of high-priced, high-margin vehicles, touting speed and power far more than sustainability.

The standardTeslas are battery sponges. A general partner at RedBlue Capital, which invests in mobility startups, says that they suck up nickel,cobalt andlithium for a vehicle that uses 4% of the time. Musk doesn't think of the mass market story as moving toward actually reducing emissions so much as increasing scale by targeting more and more segments.

Since it released the $100,000 Roadster in 2008, no automaker has played a bigger role in popularizing EV's and getting car buyers excited about them thanTesla. It has become the world's pre-eminent seller of such vehicles, posting consistent profits in recent years after a decade of losses, and is on track to deliver more than a million EV in 2022. It has been helped by a low-cost federal loan and government incentives for its customers, as well as emissions credit programs run by California, the U.S. and the European Union. As the company matures, Musk keeps his focus on increasing sales of high-priced, high-margin vehicles.

It was the initial mission that really made a difference.

Andrew said that it's generally understood to be a sort of progressive, left-leaning customer base that is quite aligned towards both a love of technology and a belief in the mission of the brand. People like that. They think in that way.

“Even standard Teslas are battery sponges. They suck up lithium, nickel and cobalt for a vehicle that's utilized 4% of the time on average.”

Dan Becker is the director of the Center for Biological Diversity and an advocate for clean, sustainable transportation since 1990. He's worried that it's following competitors by relying on heavier vehicles.

Becker said that everything has become a truck in the U.S. Although it is headed in that direction, it has been a leader as not yet having everything be a truck.

Heavy vehicles require more materials and energy. Increased safety risks for pedestrians and drivers of smaller vehicles are included in a study in the scientific journal Nature. The authors say that smaller, lighter EV are better for society.

Carbon Pollution

Musk does not extend his commitment to ending reliance on hydrocarbons to the company that uses climate-warming methane for rocket launches. His private company, Lone Star Mineral Development, has its own drilling operation, as well as leases for gas wells on its property in Texas, which is home to a massive SpaceX facility.

Musk used to think that the new models would be more affordable than the previous ones. After Musk claimed there was little demand for a promised $59,000 base version, the Model S now starts at $105,000 and sells for $100,000. In 2015, the Model X SUV started at $76,000 and went up to more than $115,000 today.

The company's top seller is the Model Y SUV, which is priced from $66,000 and weighs over 4,500 pounds. It's not known how many of the 1.5 million reservations for the Cybertruck will turn into actual orders when production begins next year.

Electric vehicles are going to be a real problem in the future. Becker said it's not when they're only a small part of the production. The trucks are going to need a lot of batteries. The batteries are going to need a lot of electricity. A lot of power plants will need those electrons.

When it comes to heavy passenger vehicles, changing to electric power from gasoline can result in a substantial reduction in carbon emissions over a vehicle's lifetime of use. Work trucks and large pickup trucks have poor fuel efficiency, getting just 16 or 17 miles per gallon of gas.

“All these trucks are going to require a lot of battery. Those batteries are going to require a lot of electrons. And those electrons are going to require a lot of power plants.”

If you replace a heavier vehicle with an EV weighing up to 9000 pounds, you will save 190 grams of carbon per mile. Replacing a small gasoline-powered passenger car for a similar-sized EV would save 140 grams per mile over the vehicle's usable life.

It takes a long time to power a vehicle with electricity instead of gasoline. Producing electric vehicles is more carbon intensive.

The production of the ICE vehicle is 60 grams per mile, while the battery-electric vehicle is 180 grams per mile. Driving is where you have all your gains.

In its environmental report, the company said it had 588,000 metric tons of annual carbon emissions from operations. The figure probably increased due to the company expanding production and sales. Last year, 8 million metric tons of carbon pollution was eliminated by the vehicles ofTesla.

It doesn't include CEO Musk's carbon emissions data, which suggests he creates an extraordinary amount by flying around the globe.

The main source of profit for the company is in China and it has recently lowered prices there. It has become a luxury brand because of the high prices of batteries. "We have enough on our plate right now, too much on our plate, frankly."

He acquired the social networking site under pressure. Since late October, there have been problems and investor skepticism that have knocked the price of the company's shares off. The stock has plummeted this year.

Musk had hoped that his company would become a solar energy superpower as well. Five years after his acquisition of SolarCity, the sales of solar panels and batteries make up just 2.5% of the company's revenue. In late 2016 Musk predicted that the solar business would add half a billion dollars to the company's balance sheet over the next three years. That didn't happen.

Climate Conferences

At COP21 in Paris in 2015, Musk spoke about the need for higher taxes on carbon-based fuels to level the playing field for cleantech.

Are you able to do anything? Talk to your politicians whenever you have the chance. He asked them to put a carbon tax in place. Fight propaganda from the carbon industry by talking to your friends.

A dedicated channel to promote news from the climate conference was fired by him seven years later. During the 12 days of the event, which warned that countries weren't moving fast enough to curb emissions of greenhouse gasses, the only climate-related statement from the company was an announcement that it was opening up its EV plug design for use by competitors.

Musk has never advocated for habits or lifestyle changes that would be helpful in slowing greenhouse gas emissions. Mass transit is very tiring. He said at a conference that it was bad.

He could have been his alternative. The tunnels beneath the Las Vegas Convention Center are narrow.

In March 2022, Musk said that his goal was to move the world from a "mine-and-burn hydrocarbon economy." extraordinary measures need to be taken.

It has run afoul of regulators and environmentalists as it scales up its production operations. The company settled a long running dispute with the EPA over toxic emissions from its plant. In Germany, where the company chopped down 165 hectares of trees to build its factory, the production ramp-up has been slower than expected. It has told local officials that it wants to drill on its land in hopes of finding more water. The plant is located in Brandenberg, where authorities are looking into whether the plant is handling hazardous materials without a permit.

Becker still praises the work done by Musk andTesla.

I worry about the weight of their vehicles and other issues. Hundreds of thousands of electric vehicles are being made byTesla. The rest of the industry was forced to say they want to do it as well. Even if Musk is crazy, I would give him credit for that.

MORE FROM FORBES