If you find a gift you like, don't act like you like it or else it's gone, that's the rule of the white elephant gift exchange.

When he joined the SNL cast for a white elephant Christmas exchange, Austin learned this hard. When it's your turn, you pick a gift and the person after you can either steal it or pick another gift. A sweet ash tray was the perfect gift for butler.

He explained that it was the perfect gift as he was looking for a way to dispose of his items when he got home. "To whoever got this, thank you for real, I'm going to treasure this for the rest of my life," he said.

Cecily Strong decided to steal Butler's gift after he declared his love for the ash tray. The man who's heart and soul has been ripped away from him is put on a masterful performance by butler.

"That's not right, you shouldn't be able to do that," he said angrily. That's mean as well.