Astronomers are interested in red dwarfs. According to some research, up to 85% of the stars in the Milky Way could be red dwarfs.

There are some issues with their habitability. There is a problem with tidal locking.

Red dwarf stars are sometimes referred to as M-dwarfs.

The terms red dwarf and M-dwarf have different meanings. An M-dwarf is defined as a red dwarf with a maximum temperature of 3,900K and a maximum mass of 0.6 solar mass.

A red dwarf is defined as a star with a maximum temperature of 5,200 K and a maximum mass of 0.8 solar mass. All main-sequence stars are included in this definition.

Part of the K-dwarf classification is only included in one red dwarf definition.

The definitions are shown in the diagram.

The definition of a red dwarf can be a bit fuzzy. Sometimes the definition included the brightest brown dwarfs, sometimes it includes all or part of the K-dwarf classification. Image Credit: By User:Spacepotato - Modified version of Image:HR-diag-no-text.svg, written by Rursus and modified by Bhutajata, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=2093830
The definition of a red dwarf can be a bit fuzzy. Sometimes the definition included the brightest brown dwarfs, and sometimes it includes all or part of the K-dwarf classification. Image Credit: By User: Spacepotato – Modified version of Image: HR-diag-no-text.svg, written by Rursus and modified by Bhutajata, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=2093830

Red dwarfs are the smallest stars in the main sequence. They live a long time because of their low mass. There are no red dwarfs in the Universe that are as big as the least massive one.

A lot of them are defined by the astronomer. If the estimate of 250 billion stars is correct, there could be more than 200 billion of them. The red dwarf stellar population is thought to have a lot of rocky planets. The astronomy community makes a point to study red dwarfs because they are like the cookie jar of exoplanets.

There are red dwarfs. It is nearly impossible to see small planets in front of other stars. Red dwarfs do not have the same light that creates an obstacle. Astronomers have found ways to work with the dimness of them.

Our closest stellar neighbour is Proxima Centauri, a red dwarf shown in the small red circle. It's too dim for the naked eye to see, but astronomers still detected three planets orbiting it. One of them is an Earth-sized planet in the red dwarf's habitable zone. The two bright stars are (left) Alpha Centauri and (right) Beta Centauri. Credit: Skatebiker at English Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Our closest stellar neighbour is Proxima Centauri, a red dwarf shown in the small red circle. It’s too dim for the naked eye, but astronomers still detected three planets orbiting it. One is an Earth-sized planet in the red dwarf’s habitable zone. The two bright stars are (left) Alpha Centauri and (right) Beta Centauri. Credit: Skatebiker at English Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 3.0)

The European Southern Observatory runs a project called "SPECULOOS", which is about searching for planets with moons. Four robotic cameras are at the Paranal Observatory.

To detect planets as they transit across small, cool stars in our neighbourhood of the Milky Way is the mission of the Spearos organization. Red dwarfs have other attempts to find them. Young M-dwarfs were analyzed by the HADES. Habitable Zones and M dwarf activity have been observed by the Hubble Space Telescope. TESS and others have studied red dwarfs because they are so numerous.

They don't have the ability to study red dwarfs in detail. The James Webb Space Telescope and powerful ground-based telescopes are currently being built. These planets have atmospheres that can be studied by those telescopes.

The goal is to narrow down the list of red dwarfs for further study. Identifying targets that can answer specific questions is crucial to observing time on these telescopes. It is getting more and more prepared for upcoming observations.

We need to understand the full range of possible M-dwarf planetary climates and their prospects for habitability.

TRAPPIST-1 is probably the most well-known ultra-cool, or red dwarf, star. It is host to several rocky, roughly Earth-sized planets. Astronomers think it's no accident that ultra-cool stars and red dwarfs are host to so many smaller, rocky planets, and they hope that SPECULOOS will find them. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech
TRAPPIST-1 is probably the most well-known ultra-cool, or red dwarf, star. It is host to several rocky, roughly Earth-sized planets. Astronomers think it’s no accident that ultra-cool stars and red dwarfs are hosts to many smaller, rocky planets, and they hope that SPECULOOS will find them. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

Many observations of M-dwarfs have been made. Astronomers don't have answers to some important questions about these stars and their planets. Are they too violent? Are they emitting too much UV and X-ray radiation? Do they remove the atmospheres of stars?

There is a big question regarding red dwarf habitability.

The habitable zones of M-dwarfs are closer to stars than they are to us. It is necessary for planets to be close to M-dwarfs. They are prevented from rotating because of their close proximity. The planets in M-dwarf are locked to their stars.

The study looked at tidally locked M-dwarf planets to understand what conditions could make their terminator regions hospitable. The study was accepted for publication in The Astronomical Journal. The lead author is a graduate student at Caltech.

A stellar eyeball region is created when a planet is locked to its star. Beyond the terminator line, the part of the planet facing the star is not warm. A planet with liquid water in the stellar eyeball can be created.

This is an artist's impression of the exoplanet TRAPPIST-1f. It's likely an example of a
This is an artist’s impression of the exoplanet TRAPPIST-1f. It’s likely an example of a “cold” eyeball planet with an ice shell pierced by an ocean on the side facing the star. Image Credit: By NASA/JPL-Caltech – Catalog page · Full-res (MOV), Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=56552366

The paper's authors give a description of their research in the introduction. In this paper, we look at the possibility of planets with terminator habitability, defined by the existence of a band at the transition between a hot dayside and a cold one.

Since the early days of exoplanet discoveries, scientists have wondered about tidally locked planets. If a planet's atmosphere circulates enough, the temperature can be moderate between the day and night. Ocean heat transport can affect day and night temperatures on exoplanets.

Water-to-land ratios can be a factor in creating a terminator zone.

This artist's illustration shows the terminator on an exoplanet. The region would experience perpetual twilight. Image Credit: Image Science and Analysis Laboratory, NASA Johnson Space Center.
This artist’s illustration shows the terminator on an exoplanet. The region would experience perpetual twilight. Image Credit: Image Science and Analysis Laboratory, NASA Johnson Space Center.

The authors modeled exoplanets with different coverage ratios. They wanted to know how the ratio affected the habitability of the planet.

The night side of these planets is likely frozen solid. The dayside could see a concentration of water that wouldn't go away. The band of habitability around the terminator could be either skinnier or broader.

The authors wrote that they explored climate at the inner edge of the M-dwarf habitable zone to determine how fractional habitability changes as dayside temperatures begin to exceed habitable limits. The authors work in a range of 0 to 50 degrees.

AD Leonis is the focus of the paper. AD Leonis is a well-understood star that is representative of brighter red dwarf stars, so they chose it. It is only 16 light-years away from the Sun, so it is easy to see. The flaring activity of AD Leonis was not included in the study.

An artist's illustration of the nearby red dwarf AD Leonis, also known as Gliese 388. Like other red dwarfs, it's known to flare violently, but flaring wasn't part of this study. Image Credit: National Astronomical Observatory of Japan.
This is an artist’s illustration of the nearby red dwarf AD Leonis, also known as Gliese 388. Like other red dwarfs, it’s known to flare violently, but flaring wasn’t part of this study. Image Credit: National Astronomical Observatory of Japan.

Two sets of simulations were performed by the researchers. Water-abundant aquaplanets and water limited land planets were involved in one set. The team looked at the results to see how the planets would be.

The starting point for this simulation was a planet named Aq34, which has an Earth-like solar constant and a mostly sunny dayside climate.

This image from the study shows the simulated planets. The researchers simulated six aquaplanets and 3 land planets. Image Credit: Lobo et al. 2022
This image from the study shows the simulated planets. The researchers simulated six aquaplanets and three land planets. Image Credit: Lobo et al. 2022

Some of the variables produced different results. A greenhouse gas can be created by a higher planetary temperature. It also means more cloud cover. It can raise the planet's albedo and help it stay cooler.

This figure from the study shows how variables can have competing effects. (a) shows the surface temperature and winds. (b) shows the mid-troposphere height and wind patterns. (c) shows top-of-atmosphere albedo. (d) shows the surface evaporation rates and precipitation reaching the
surface in yellow contours. (c) shows that regions with abundant clouds reflect a larger fraction of incoming SW (shortwave flux or stellar radiation,) which reduces warming in the stellar eye but also increases the greenhouse effect. Image Credit: Lobo et al. 2022
This figure from the study shows how variables can have competing effects. (a) shows the surface temperature and winds. (b) shows the mid-troposphere height and wind patterns. (c) shows top-of-atmosphere albedo. (d) shows the surface evaporation rates and precipitation reaching the

The show shows that regions with abundant clouds reflect a larger fraction of incoming SW, reducing warming in the stellar eye but also increasing the greenhouse effect. The image is from Lobo et al..

For a planet to have a terminator zone, it must have a large swing between daytime and nighttime temperatures. In order for terminator habitability to occur, a planet must sustain large day-night temperature gradient. The terminator region can only be created by that dynamic.

The research shows that planets in the ocean aren't capable of producing a terminator region. One of these planets is close to the red dwarf, which reduces the difference between daytime and nighttime temperatures. Before the dayside reached a runaway greenhouse effect, those planets would produce a homogeneity of climates. They didn't pass through a state where the terminator was safe.

Water- limited planets didn't fare well. Large day-night temperature gradients are easy to achieve without entering a runaway greenhouse state. That helps create a hospitable environment for terminators. The water- limited land planet configurations may be favorable in terms of long-term climate stability.

Aquaplanet simulations that seek to reproduce ocean-covered planets but can easily occur on water- limited land planets are not able to reproduce a terminator.

The water content of red dwarfs is difficult to determine. It is possible to measure how much a planet tugs on its star with the help of a radial velocity study. A planet with a lower density may have more water. Those are not sure.

Water-limited exoplanets may be more abundant than water-abundant planets, but more research is needed to solidify that understanding. It would bode well for habitability if it is true. The authors say that terminator habitability may be a fraction of the planets.

If a terminator is more likely on water- limited exoplanets, that could affect the possibility of life. Life requires water. There was a lack of surface water in the simulations.

The team writes that the situation poses a challenge for life.

Some variables on these planets are not clear. Glaciers on the planet's nightside may not have enough water. The world is too hot if the atmosphere is so thick. More research is needed to answer those questions.

This artist's illustration shows an eyeball world with all of the water frozen into glaciers on the nightside and the dayside totally barren. Image Credit: By Ittiz - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=114028109
This artist’s illustration shows an eyeball world with all the water frozen into glaciers on the nightside and the dayside totally barren. Image Credit: By Ittiz – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=114028109

There needs to be more research into red dwarf planets. Astronomers can use this study to find good targets for follow-up observations with the James Webb telescope. In their final comment, the authors acknowledge their limitations.

Future studies exploring a broader range of land planet configurations, particularly those using future generations of surface and ice models, will find a wide range of habitable terminator scenarios.

More: