This week, Henry Cavill reprised his role as a hulking and slightly less capable sleuth in Enola Holmes 2, as he did in the first one. The actor made a brief appearance at the end of Black Adam. It was clear his new take on the Last Son of Krypton would be different from the one he played in previous DCEU entries when his seconds on screen sent fans into a frenzy.

Over the weekend, there was a bombshell report about his exit from the show. After the show's account posted the news, he made a vague statement about his leaving. The news shocked the business, with few, if any, outlets anticipating the announcement, and immediately started pointing fingers, even though they didn't know what to think.

It is difficult to see an actor leave a beloved role when the actor does a good job. The abruptness of the news and the lack of clarity about his motives made his exit from the show even more delicate. The rumors are not good for anyone. Forsaking a role that critics and audiences agree was meant for him may be a mistake. While playing the Man of Steel in a major motion picture might seem more appealing than spending four more seasons slumming in the Continent, Geralt might be the role that was born to be played by him.

Cavill respects The Witcher’s character and lore

Geralt sitting on a tree and looking tired in The Witcher.

The show itself has always been controversial despite the positive experience of the man. The first season of the show earned a mediocre 32% on the Tomatoes. The performances were praised, but the writing was mixed. Critics and fans agreed that the show had potential and that it was unbalanced in its first season. Critics praised the tone, performances, and the more focused plot of the second season of The Witcher. Fans didn't like the new season.

The show made a lot of changes to the source material, such as changing major storylines, and playing fast and loose with the lore. Whenever an adaptation changes aspects of the source material, there will always be controversy. Everyone in front of and behind the camera is confused by the lack of a clear vision of what the game wants to be. The show marketed itself as an adaptation of the novels, despite the fact that the games are very clear about being distinct stories. It didn't live up to its promise.

He talked about how he wanted to be faithful to the books during the tour. He said that it was difficult to reconcile his love for the books with the show's vision.

He is a poster child for the geek community, as he loves his PC, plays World of Warcraft, and brags about his love for fantasy novels. He doesn't mind being called the King of the Nerds. If the King of Nerds is unhappy with his show, it must be because the show's producers aren't taking the source material seriously. Rumors surrounding The Witcher's production seem to confirm what his fans think.

Geralt with his hands on a table looking serious in The Witcher.

A few weeks ago, Beau De Mayo, who worked as a writer on The Witcher, claimed that several of the show's writers "actively disliked the books and games" and "mocked the source material." The creative minds behind the show seem to misunderstand the source material. A major piece of news came out after season 2's premiere, in which Lauren Hissrich confessed that the re-enactment of Roach's death scene was different from the original one.

The second season of the show was divisive and the writer's room disliked the source material. His fans think the show failed him, while trades and Insiders try to beat each other to find the real reason for his departure. Some are wondering if he should have left the show since the ink on his contract is still wet. Was he justified in leaving? It's probably not.

He’s a better fit for Geralt than Superman

Geralt looking confused in in The Witcher.

Why is Geralt convincing and compelling? He fits the bill in a number of ways. The guy's arms are the size of tree trunks and his thighs are large enough to burst out of his pants. There is a resemblance to a hero or a monster hunter in this picture. The wig looked cheap in the first season, but the screen presence of the man was overwhelming.

Even though he doesn't have a physical trait, Cavill knows Geralt. The White Wolf is a complex character in the books and games and is a wannabe philosopher. Geralt has a dry sense of humor and is curious. He is a softie and struggling with feelings of inadequacy despite his hulking appearance. Geralt is a hopeful person. He struggles to maintain his humanity in a world that constantly tries to deprive him of it and makes the best out of his nomadic lifestyle.

He uses all this in his portrayal of Geralt. The guy embodies Geralt perfectly, even though he doesn't have acting skills. During the first season of the show, the actor embodies Geralt's main qualities easily. He is looking from the corner to see what is happening. His friends and allies are kept at a distance while he is gentle. He is hesitant before every action he takes and afraid to make a mistake like he has done before.

The second season gives him more time to explore Geralt's mind. He placed his tender side front and center as he found himself caring for Ciri and mourning the supposedly dead Yennefer to complete his portrayal of Geralt. A comprehensive take on a character who defies people's expectations was created. Like the Geralt on the page, Cavill's Geralt is a pleasant surprise that brings a warm smile to your face.

His passion for Geralt was clear. There was a man who wanted to be Geralt. The actors are passionate about their roles. Many high-profile jobs are taken for the paycheck and to get a major franchise. He made everyone know that he loved The Witcher.

Liam is an okay actor. He is not a movie star but he is not terrible. It's hard not to think of the replacement as a poor man's excuse when you have someone like Cavill who set the bar high and had genuine passion for the project. Hemsworth is going to be set up for failure by the two companies. Unless this man gets Andrzej Sapkowski into a room and writes a thousand-page thesis on Geralt's mental state, chances are his efforts will pale in comparison to Cavill's.

The White Wolf or the Last Son of Krypton?

Superman gazes in the distance in an image from Henry Cavill's Instagram.

It is hard not to think that the chance to wear the red cape again gave him the motivation to leave the ship. The Man of Steel is a pop culture icon with an indelible place in our imagination. No one would say no to playing him.

One can't help but think that Cavill is better suited to Geralt than Superman. The Last Son of Krypton is a boy scout who is also a mama's boy and a trooper. Superman can only be found in comic books. He is too much but doesn't bother anyone. He is the epitome of sunshine. It is hard to portray that. Only a few actors have succeeded in their roles.

While he can portray a hopeful and positive Superman, can he live up to the expectation of millions of people? Fans have been clamoring for his return since he hasn't been Superman in five years. The very best version of the Man of Steel will be expected by them. The only thing that will suffice is for Cavill to be perfect.

There is an animal in the room. He represents the beginning of the DCEU and his return would mean restoring a director's vision. He made it clear that he doesn't want anything to do with the current version of Superman.

Will those fans support the new take or the old one? When he first took on the role of Superman, he faced a lot of challenges. There is an amount of time. Does he still have room for his hero? Is there still a crowd or was the noise to bring him back?

With Geralt, the character was so appealing that it made him a major player in pop culture. If he had a problem with the behind-the-scenes talent, would he be able to change their approach to the show? The fans would have supported him. Is the best choice not Geralt? It would have been bad to say goodbye to Superman, but he had an entire continent to make up for it.

The deed is done, and Henry Cavill is no longer the player in the game. We can probably say goodbye to the proposed seven-season plan for the show. I don't think it will make it past the first season. Time will tell if Superman is a success or failure. There is a split in the Superman camp about whether or not he is a good choice to play the role. The DCEU is on the verge of collapse and James and Peter will do everything they can to keep it going. That could include him if he plays his cards right. We could see a new Man of Steel in years if he doesn't do well in his take on Superman. All this mess was for nothing.

You can watch the first two seasons of the show on the internet. Man of Steel can be watched on the pay per view channel. Don't bother with the justice league.

Editors' Recommendations