Spiderhead was seen for 35 million hours in its first week of release. The existence of a lavishly made non-franchise sci-fi success is supposed to make any sci-fi head happy. Spiderhead is not a good one. There is a lot of work that needs to be done here.
It is possible to read a piece of investigative journalism about a bizarre prison experiment and tsk-tsk or experience it yourself in America in the year 2022. Four men were treated for Covid-19 in Arkansas and soon began to suffer side effects including vision problems, bloody stools, and stomach pains. They found out later that they had been prescribed high amounts of ivermectin without their consent.
Kosinksi uses bombast to treat the material. You will have to punch someone if you are experimenting on them. The candid response is more of a scream of horror. I can't help but think that a different set of actors could have handled the situation. The actors can seem cowed by the world. Are you talking about Jesse Eisenberg? Are you talking about Michael Shannon? Is itJessie Buckley?
The short storySaunders had the potential to be a contained, introspective sci-fi chamber piece in the vein of Ex Machina, according to the article. It reminds me of the movie's famous dance scene.
Alex Garland said that the scene came from an instinct to put something in his movie that would wake people up. You can laugh at it, but you need to laugh at it. There is something within Ex Machina. Whatever this is, that's fine.
It makes me think about the sci-fi-y Charlie Kaufman movies, or Bong Joon-ho's happily over-the-top Snowpiercer, or the recent work-life-balance parable Severance. A head of state is blackmailed into having sex with a pig on television. It's my favorite episode of the show. sci-fi can get a little dumb if it isn't obsessed with grand Manichean conflict.
The end of Spiderhead is a pat action set piece through which every major character secures their correct fate. It should be noted that a similar mistake was made by the author of the short story. If sci-fi at its best reflects not what being alive right now looks like but what it feels like, then the honest move is letting that scream go on forever.